Vector databases have recently gained prominence with the rise of large language models and generative AI. A vector database is a data store for unstructured text in the form of vector embeddings for various AI models and applications. Embeddings are a high dimensional vector representation of text that conveys rich semantic information and represent an efficient way of capturing unstructured data like text.
The rising popularity of large language models like GPT-4, Gemini, Claude-2, Llama-2, Mixtral and others have fuelled tremendous interest in generative AI across the industry to build applications based on these models. Vector databases are specialized for handling vector data that is used to train or fine-tune these foundational models for domain and company specific use cases. Unlike traditional scalar-based databases, vector databases offer optimized storage and querying capabilities for vector embeddings. Although several vector databases are now available in the market like Pinecone, Chroma, Qdrant amongst others, deciding which vector database to choose for enterprise use cases is not a straightforward decision. In this article, you will learn how to decide which vector database to choose for your organization based on criteria like performance, reliability, scalability, cost-efficiency, developer experience, security, technical support amongst others. Key Considerations In this section, you will learn in detail about each of the key factors that should be considered to make your final selection of a vector database. These include data and use case characteristics, performance, functionality, enterprise-readiness, developer experience, and future roadmap. 1. Data and Use Case It is important to work backwards from the specific business use case that you are planning to solve by leveraging organizational data and the latest techniques from the field of generative AI. For instance, if your business objective is to build an enterprise knowledge management chatbot like McKinsey’s Lilli, you will need to organize and prepare all the in-house text data such as documents, emails, chat messages etc. The use case defines several aspects of the data, including its size, frequency, data type, growth in the volume of data over time, data freshness and consequently the nature of the underlying vector embeddings to be stored in the vector database. These vectors may be sparse, dense, and also span multiple modalities depending on the use case. Additionally, careful planning and scoping of the use case also helps you understand other crucial aspects such as the number of users, the number of queries per day, the peak number of queries at any given instant, as well as the query patterns of the users. Vector databases utilize indexing and vector search powered by k-nearest neighbors (kNN) or approximate nearest neighbor (ANN) algorithms. This empowers a vector db to perform similarity search and identify the most similar vectors in the database. This capability underlies enterprise use cases based on natural language processing such as question-answering, document analysis, recommender systems, image and voice recognition etc. 2. Performance 2.1 Query latency and query per second (QPS) The primary performance metrics of a vector db are the query latency, i.e., the time it takes to run a query and get the result and the query per second that defines the throughput in terms of the number of queries processed in a second. These parameters are critical for ensuring a seamless user experience for several applications that require real-time results such as chatbots. Typical QPS values range from ~50-300 and the average query latency from 25-100 ms depending on the underlying hardware. 2.2 Scalability Scalability measures the ability of the vector database to grow and expand further to support the requirements of its customers. The scale can be measured in terms of the number of embeddings that can be supported and in terms of horizontal scaling of existing resources and vertical scaling of additional servers. Typically, most existing vector db companies provide scale-out capabilities up to a billion vectors without any performance degradation. If the resources can scale automatically, then you can be rest assured that your application will always be up and running. 2.3 Accuracy A vector database is as good as its accuracy of retrieving the right set of results based on the user queries. Here, the choice of vector search algorithms to identify data sources with similar embeddings as the embedding of the user query is pivotal. There are several different algorithms used for powering vector search such as kNN, ANN, FAISS, NGT. These algorithms generate approximate results and the best vector databases provide a good trade-off between speed and accuracy. 3. Functionality 3.1 Filtering on metadata In practice, filtering vector search results based on the metadata helps reduce the search space, thus providing for faster and more accurate search results. Typical metadata includes information like dates, versions, tags and the ability of a vector database to store multiple metadata fields allows for a better search experience. 3.2 Integrations Integrating a vector database into the existing data and engineering infrastructure in your organization is critical to faster adoption and lesser time to value. The ability of vector databases to seamlessly integrate with essential infrastructure elements like the cloud infrastructure, underlying large language models, databases etc. is a key factor to consider. 3.3 Cost-efficiency While performance metrics and functionality are core to a technology, the cost should be reasonable and fit your budget. The pricing of vector databases is a function of the number of ‘write’ operations such as update and delete and the number of queries. Other factors that affect the cost include the dimensionality of the embedding, the number of vectors stored in the database, and the size of the metadata. Depending on your use case and requirements, it is essential to estimate the overall cost of running your application at scale on a monthly or quarterly basis and evaluate the overall costs relative to your budget and the expected revenue from running the AI applications. 4. Enterprise-readiness 4.1 Security and compliance For most enterprise companies, it is imperative that any external vendor they employ meets strict security and compliance requirements. These requirements include SOC2, GDPR, HIPAA, ISO compliance and others, depending on the domain in which the company operates. The data privacy and security standards have gone up in the light of recent cybersecurity attacks and breaches of customer data, and you should ensure that any vector db vendor meets your specific security and compliance requirements. 4.2 Cloud setup Several modern companies have undergone digital transformation and house their entire data and infrastructure in the cloud vs on-premise. You may choose to manage and maintain your infrastructure via a self-hosted setup or go for a fully managed SaaS platform. The benefit of a fully managed system is that it automates clusters with minimal requirements for you to provision and scale clusters or take care of operational issues. 4.3 Availability Availability, i.e. the ability of your vector db to run without any interruptions, issues or downtime is essential to not adversely impact user experience. Most vector database providers vouch for specific SLAs which should meet the requirements for your applications. Typical values include 99.9% for uptime SLA and a few hours to a few business days for response time SLA depending on the severity of the production issue. 4.4 Technical support More often than not, you might be stuck facing some issues with your vector db and need some hands-on support from the vendor to help troubleshoot the issue. Does the company provide you with a dedicated team who can be available at a short notice to get on a call and figure out how to solve the problem? The quality of responsiveness and customer support experience provided by a vector db company is valuable and helps you develop a stronger sense of trust in the company. 4.5 Open source vs Closed source Some vector db companies are closed source and operate under a proprietary license such as Pinecone. At the same time, there are a host of vector db companies that are open source under the Apache 2.0 license such as Qdrant or Chroma while also offering a fully managed service. This can also influence your choice of the vector db provider. 5. Developer experience 5.1 Community Software and AI engineers are the core professionals who will work on the vector db and integrate it in the company’s infrastructure and deploy your generative AI application to production. Therefore, the quality of experience that developers have with a vector db solution is integral in shaping your final decision. Having an open-source community on Slack or Discord helps build more engagement and trust with developers than commercial vendor support. It provides your developers an opportunity to learn from developers at other companies as well and discuss and solve issues by leveraging the wisdom of the community. 5.2 Onboarding Onboarding a new technology is challenging as it determines the time your developer team takes to properly understand the product, integrate it, troubleshoot any issues, and become an expert in using the vector database. The availability of APIs and SDKs as well as clear product demos and documentation goes a long way in reducing the barriers to understanding a new vector database so that your developers can build with speed and confidence. 5.3 Time to value Similar to the time to onboard a new vector db, another important factor is the time to business value. If a vector db provider vouches for a fast deployment of a production-ready application, then you can realize value sooner, and meet your business goals faster as well. A long gestation time from onboarding to business value is a deterrent for many fast-moving companies and startups especially in the current frantic race to adopt and ship generative AI applications. 5.4 Documentation The quality of the vector database’s documentation determines the time to onboard, time to value, and trust in the provider’s expertise and product. Clear instructions with tutorials, examples and case studies help your developers understand and master the vector db faster. 5.5 User education Similar to community-based offerings, expert technical content such as blogs, demos and videos focused on the existing as well as new features are helpful for your team to understand and build faster. In addition to text and video content, other offerings like user testimonials, workshops, conferences also help educate your team and build more trust in the vector db provider. 6. Future roadmap A final factor to consider is the product roadmap of the vector database provider. Vector databases are an emerging technology that will need to continuously evolve alongside the advances in generative AI models, chip design and hardware, and novel enterprise use cases across domains. Therefore, the vector db vendor should show the potential for evaluating long-term and future industry trends such as sophisticated vectorization techniques for a wider variety of data types, hybrid databases, optimized hardware accelerators for AI applications such as GPUs and TPUs, distributed vector dbs, real-time and streaming data based applications, as well as industry-specific solutions that might require advance data privacy and security. Conclusion Vector databases are an essential ingredient for modern generative AI applications built on unstructured data such as text. Their popularity has increased in parallel to the developments in the generative AI field such as large language models, large image models etc. to serve as the underlying database for handling high-dimensional data stored as vector embeddings. In this article, you learned about several important pillars to help your decision making about the choice of the vector database. These factors include data and use case considerations, performance-based requirements such as query speed and scalability, functionality requirements such integrations and cost-efficiency, enterprise-readiness including security and compliance, and developer experience including community and documentation. Several vector database companies have emerged to build this foundational infrastructure. There is no single ‘best’ vendor of vector db and the ultimate choice is highly contingent on your organization’s business goals. Therefore, a data-driven approach guided by the factors listed in this article will help you select the most optimal vector db for your organization.
Comments
|
Archives
October 2024
Categories
All
Copyright © 2024, Sundeep Teki
All rights reserved. No part of these articles may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the author. Disclaimer
This is a personal blog. Any views or opinions represented in this blog are personal and belong solely to the blog owner and do not represent those of people, institutions or organizations that the owner may or may not be associated with in professional or personal capacity, unless explicitly stated. |